Tweed Overruled; DeLauro’s Sunroom OK’d

by Melissa Bailey | May 10, 2007 5:19 PM | | Comments (3)

rosa.JPGA man hoping to build a house near the Tweed Airport runway, a towing company with its eye on Wooster Square, and U.S. Rep. Rosa DeLauro (pictured), who hopes to expand her sun room, all learned their fate from the city zoning board.

DeLauro didn’t join the ranks of citizens pleading for backyard decks and liquor licenses before the Board of Zoning Appeals Tuesday. Meeting no opposition from East Rock neighbors, no fiery oration was needed to convince the board to allow her fix-up plans.

DeLauro lives with her husband, Stanley Greenberg, in a 1907 colonial home at 49 Huntington St., a baseball’s throw away from the embattled site of the new Hooker school. She appealed to the board for a modest addition to the home, to extend the kitchen area and a sun room. She asked for a modest side yard variance — 10 feet where 12 feet are required — to allow for the addition to the rear of her house. Without controversy, the request was approved in a 5-0 BZA vote Tuesday.

Attorney Anthony “Zony Tony” Avallone (pictured), the former state senator who has made a career of representing clients at BZA meetings, had two proposals on the table.

One — a proposal by Crown Towing to relocate a towing facility to 10 Olive St. in Wooster Square — met strong opposition last month from neighbors who charged it would ruin the neighborhood’s familial, historic charm. The requests — a special exception to allow limited auto sales in a BA zone, and a use variance permitting vehicular storage — also met opposition from the area’s alderman, Mike Smart. In a divided 3-2 vote, board members denied both requests: Chairwoman Cathy Weber, Gaylord Bourne, and Regina Winters voted to deny; Maritza Padilla-Gant and Chris Vigilante voted to approve.

Avallone’s other clients’ proposal fared better, despite lobbying from Tweed-New Haven Airport seeking to block the project. His clients, William and Lisa Stone, live in a home at 409/411 Burr St., adjacent to airport property and neighboring the East Haven border.

The Stones planned to split their lot in two, making it an L-shaped “flag lot,” leaving another parcel closer to Burr Street open to be built upon. A city zoning officer signed off on the lot split, apparently prematurely, before BZA approval was sought. The couple just needed new yard and coverage variances to make the existing house conform to rules on the newly shrunken lot.

Tweed took the opportunity to sweep in with a counter-lobby opposing new construction near its runway.

“In certain locations at the end of the runway, you really have to look carefully before you allow any new development,” attorney Hugh Manke told the board. New development is not a “compatible use” with nearby airport activity, he argued.

The City Plan Department also opposed the request, arguing the Stones’ hardship was self-inflicted. The Tweed factor wasn’t part of its report, but City Plan chief Karyn Gilvarg weighed in: “There is potentially a safety issue with a new dwelling that close to the runway.”

Avallone argued the board needed to be consistent with its zoning officer’s action to split the lot. And, he noted, the building didn’t pierce the new 3-D runway protection zone designed to protect airplane’s paths from building interference. He argued the Stones do have hardship, because of the setback distance from Burr and because the city doesn’t recognize the access road as an official street.

In two separate votes, board members first unanimously rejected City Plan’s advice and sided with Avallone, then voted 4-1 to approve the plans.

In other news, Amistad Academy’s proposal to temporarily relocate to the Boulevard until it builds a new K-8 school was unanimously approved.







Share this story: digg / newsvine / facebook

Comments

Posted by: Esbe [TypeKey Profile Page] | May 10, 2007 7:59 PM


Now wait a minute -- aren't the folks who live near the airport always telling us that the worse possible thing is to live near an airport and we really need to shut it down so their lives become bearable? And these folks now argue, and convince the BZA, that it would be a horrible burden for them not to be able to build a new house right at the end of the airport runway?

Not to be too cynical, but I suppose it is a win-win for the builders. Either they succeed in closing Tweed, and pocket a pretty penny, or else Tweed is eventually able to expand the runway -- and these folks sell-out to the airport at a profit. The only losers are the rest of us!

Posted by: cedarhillresident [TypeKey Profile Page] | May 10, 2007 10:01 PM

Here is were I get non contructive...

Rosa DeLauro I am your biggest fan! :) Happy for your appoval

Posted by: charlie | May 11, 2007 9:48 AM

Crown Towing is a 24 hour use that adds traffic to a street, making it safer. One towing place is not a big deal, but when you have a bunch, then it gets annoying and lowers property values. Now of course the NIMBYism means that it's going to have to go to the Hill or some other neighborhood that already has more than its fair share of such facilities. Great job, Wooster Square.

A variance for Crown Towing clearly should have been granted --- unless the city is anticipating something better to happen on Olive Street like a shopping mall with 10 story apartments above. Which I doubt.

Sorry, Comments are closed for this entry

Sections

Neighborhood News

Special Sections

Legal Notices

Some Favorite Sites

Government/ Community Links


Legal Notices

Flyerboard

Sponsors

N.H.I. Site Design & Development

NHI Store

Buy New Haven Independent Stuff

News Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35