Will The Count Measure Up?

by Melinda Tuhus | July 28, 2009 11:30 AM | | Comments (3)

norma%20r-r.JPGWith the 2010 census fast approaching, community activists noted what they call a contradiction. The feds want census workers to come from the communities they’re counting. Meanwhile, federal regulations prohibit the hiring of non-citizens.

Mayor John DeStefano welcomed several dozen people, from city agencies, non-profits, local businesses and census officials, to the Hall of Records on Orange Street Monday to kick off the city’s efforts to count every resident.

“And we understand that just getting something in the mail is not going to do that,” he said. “We’ve got to go knock on doors — and oftentimes, it’ll depend on who’s doing the knocking.”

Census workers will fan out across the city to visit their neighbors. Local groups and faith communities will be encouraged to hold events to educate residents — whether citizens, legal immigrants, or undocumented individuals.

Money and clout are at stake in the count, officials said.

If New Haven does a better job this time around counting all its residents, the city will gain both political clout in state and federal legislatures, and federal funding, hopefully more than the $25 million the city received for the current year. “I think we can do better” than barely more than half the residents filling out the census form, said City Plan Director Karyn Gilvarg, the local point person for the census effort.

City and census officials emphasized the importance of hiring workers from their own communities to do that door knocking, to reduce fear on the part of some residents and also to handle the challenges of non-English speakers.

DeStefano said New Haven is considered a hard-to-count community because it is made up of 75 percent renters and many recent immigrants. Census workers will seek to track down everyone who doesn’t mail back a census form.

kathleen%20ludgate.JPGKathleen Ludgate (pictured) is the director of the Boston Regional Census Center, covering New England. She said her region will run a paid ad campaign in 16 languages to try to reach everyone. She explained the benefits of counting every resident, both for political representation in Congress and for eligibility for federal grants. Click here for a list of 50 city programs funded with federal dollars.

Gilvarg said that in the 2000 census, the city’s response rate was 52 percent, while Connecticut’s was 70 percent and the national average was 67 percent. Within the city, response rates in the different census tracts varied from 35.2 percent (downtown) to 73 percent in Westville. Click here to see the map.

Ludgate explained that in the first phase of the process, workers went out to count the number of dwellings, to provide a current data base for follow-up. Newhallville Alderman Charles Blango questioned whether local people were hired for that task. The head of the Bridgeport census office (which has included New Haven up to now, though New Haven will soon get its own office) said yes — almost 300 people for Greater New Haven. which includes the city and 15 surrounding towns.

sandra%20mckinnie.JPGThen Sandra McKinnie, director of financial asset development at the Community Action Agency (pictured) stood up to say, “I, like Mr. Blango, am concerned about people being hired from the community.” She said she is also concerned about the historical under-counting of African Americans and other minorities. But she added that her agency has been a partner with the Census Bureau since February, when dozens of neighborhood residents were hired to do the dwellings count.

“So many people had no idea that this [participating in the census] could make a difference between getting more books in their kids’ schools or providing more senior services,” she said later. That’s because the funding for many federal programs is divvied up based at least partly on population.

Three times more workers than were hired already will be hired to go door to door to ask residents to fill out the form. “It’s ten questions in ten minutes in 2010,” Ludgate said.

In years past (dating to the birth of the nation), residents were asked to fill out the “long form” in every year ending in a “0,” i.e., every decade. In recent years the Bureau switched to the American Community Survey, which every year asks a part of the population to fill out that long form, to ensure that the detailed data will not be outdated so fast.

Norma Rodriguez Reyes (pictured at the top of the story) said she thought it was a contradiction to hire only citizens, when some of the most “hard to count” residents are immigrants, especially undocumented immigrants who might fear to answer any questions posed by a stranger. “They’re not going to trust [an outsider] as much as someone who is of their own, asking them to fill it out.”

Ludgate answered that federal law requires the hiring of citizens except in cases where citizens are not available to take the positions.

Ecuadorean%20consul.JPGRaul Erazo Velarde (pictured), the Ecuadorean consul general for Connecticut, who’s based in New Haven, seconded Rodriguez-Reyes’s concerns. (New Haven’s recent influx of Ecuadorean immigrants prompted the establishment of the consul’s office. Click here for a story on that.) He told a reporter afterward that one must follow the law in hiring employees who are citizens, but he still hopes a way might be found to hire some non-citizens to go door to door in heavily immigrant neighborhoods.







Share this story

Share |

Comments

Posted by: LANCE | July 28, 2009 12:30 PM

if they are illegals they should be kicked the heck out of the country. ... but the liberals like obama and destafano don't care because they adhere to the rules for radicals alinksy theory that illegals are possible future votes. that is the main if not only concern of theirs.

Posted by: Westville Mike | July 28, 2009 2:49 PM

I spent a few weeks canvassing neighborhoods for the Census Bureau this spring, where I verified residential mailing addresses in preparation for the mass-mailing in 2010. Quick thoughts:
1) I was impressed with the cross-section of America on our 20-person team, which canvassed most of central, west and south New Haven - whites, blacks, Hispanics, old, young, male, female. Yes, we were all U.S. citizens (every federal employee has to be), and we were all New Haven residents.
2) In knocking on thousands of doors, I had only one person refuse to answer my simple questions (e.g. "Is this a place of residence that should be mailed a Census form next year?"). Everyone I encountered was friendly and interested in the process. One day, I even ran into 2 people who explained how their jobs within the social services sector depend upon accurate Census data.
3) I got a great tan.
4) Part of the canvassing process was to log probable homeless camps, in support of a later headcount. The Bureau is honestly trying to count everyone, whether in dorms, shelters or outdoors. I personally logged 4 or 5 homeless camps during my tours.
5) I've worked in government before, and share typical opinions of governmental bureaucracy and inefficiency. But I was pretty impressed with the Bureau's ability to raise and train an army of canvassers quickly. As an engineer, I was also impressed with completeness and logic of the canvassing process. In the end, our team completed the city in half the estimated time.
6) FILL OUT AND COMPLETE THE CENSUS FORMS NEXT YEAR. If you don't, a Census canvasser will visit your home over and over and over again until they get your answers. I'll guess and say it costs the government an extra $10 for every form not returned - that's the true wastefulness in the process. Besides, your responses are confidential. Name and address are only logged to understand who responded and who didn't. After that, it's suppressed and never shared with any government agency, by law.
7) The Bureau's website is pretty good - check out http://2010.census.gov/2010census/.

Posted by: visitor | July 28, 2009 4:04 PM

To Lance:
The fact that the census is counting everyone regardless of citizenship or immigration status have nothing to do with Obama/DeStefano/radicals/Alinsky, etc. The purpose of the census is to count people and where they are located, period.

Want to know where these rules come from? Check out the US Constitution. Maybe you'd like to move to a less radcial, Alinsky-like country?

Sections

Neighborhood News

Special Sections

Legal Notices

Some Favorite Sites

Government/ Community Links


Flyerboard

Sponsors

N.H.I. Site Design & Development

NHI Store

Buy New Haven Independent Stuff

News Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35