They Don’t Need Editors

by Abram Katz | October 30, 2009 7:45 AM | | Comments (6)

HPIM0660.JPGIn Jason Silva’s and Max Lugavere’s newspaperless future, everyone with a computer and an idea will be able to disseminate their views on the Web, without worrying about editors, fairness, or objectivity.

And that will be great, said Silva and Lugavere (right to left in photo), who co-founded the Emmy-winning “Current TV” Internet video-news citizen journalism channel with help from former Vice President Al Gore.

Their work also appears as a show on cable television, mostly in short segments. The website has a ton of content. Little of it, if any, is apparently edited before posting.

(Click here and here to sample.)

Silva and Lugavere spoke Thursday night on “Media Revolution: Putting The Media in the Hands of Citizen Journalists,” at the Joseph Slifka Center for Jewish Life at at Yale.
Both dabbled in filmmaking while undergraduates at Yale. Now their Current TV claims some 60 million subscriber households.

Twenty years ago people with interesting or provocative ideas had no way to communicate them outside of a close circle of friends, they argued.

“Now, new technology is changing the way we communicate,” Silva said.

“The website appeared to democratize communication. We just jumped at the opportunity,” Lugavere said.

They specialized in brief documentaries, which have become easier to create thanks to improved cameras and software. User-generated content on Current TV is not rare, they said.

Nor does much of it go through the editorial process that the now disintegrating newspaper industry used to use to ensure accuracy, objectivity and fairness.

No one reads Silva’s or Lugavere’s comments before the duo airs them.

They seemed slightly puzzled when asked about the concept of an “editor.”

After their talk and warm reception, Silva and Lugavere agreed that hundreds, thousands or millions of groups with a message could follow the same route they did to spread information or misinformation. They’re the editors.

Rational, intelligent commentary will expose the extreme anti-choice, pro-gun, anti-immigration, crypto-fascist, radical, bomb-making, socially maladjusted and their webcasts, Silva and Lugavere said.

But with say, 20,000 Web TV shows to monitor, who could possibly view each one? Having thousands of channels is practically like having no channels at all.

Newspapers, which exert some control over their content, will not disappear, they said. But newsprint will go the way of vinyl records. You’ll get the paper of your choice — just electronically, on a Kindle, Sony or Nook type device, they said.

As newspapers wither so will news on Google, Yahoo, and other freeloaders, they agreed.

Silva and Lugavere pointed out that they are not attempting to produce a “news” show.

“We try to be like your most interesting Facebook friend, on TV,” Lugavere said. “We want to be like junior Bill Mahers,” Silva said.

Except that comedian/commentator Bill Maher attributes his information to newspapers, which is also where Google News plucks its items without paying the reporters who wrote them.

Open-source information (no attribution, qualification, or verification) will become more widespread, they said.

Oh, Brave new world, as Aldous Huxley said.

Or was it Shakespeare?

It’s only a fact. No matter. Ask my editor.







Share this story

Share |

Comments

Posted by: Been Called Worse | October 30, 2009 8:00 AM

everyone with a computer and an idea will be able to disseminate their views on the Web, without worrying about editors, fairness, or objectivity.

Welcome to 2002.

Posted by: streever | October 30, 2009 8:23 AM

I hate to be negative, but I have to agree with the first comment ;-) but good luck & I hope they surprise us all with something really innovative.

Posted by: Been Called Worse | October 30, 2009 9:22 AM

As newspapers wither so will news on Google, Yahoo, and other freeloaders, they agreed.

IIRC, both Google and Yahoo have contracts with AP for news feeds (as most all newsprint papers do) so I wouldn't call that freeloading.

Additionally, Google is more of a news aggregator by scanning the web and returning categorized results of recent stories. With the exception of their Associated Press licensed content, they always link back to the source news website. I always looked at it as being the newspaper's problem that they couldn't find a workable way to monetize the link-backs.

I do not think Google and Yahoo will necessarily wither along with traditional newspaper websites. The content will just be replaced with whatever the more relevant replacement is. I just hope its not tweets.

Posted by: streever | October 30, 2009 9:50 PM

(why is this one a debate? It's just me and "Been called worse" agreeing!)

Posted by: walt bradley | October 31, 2009 5:28 PM

for the last 17 years the people of new haven (as well as hamden and west haven) have had their own cable television stations - 3 of them actually - to create videos and express themselves - only without censorship, commercialism or not knowing weather they were good enough to get on television.
Citizens Television has been serving this community for years, and yet still does not get the respect or mention it deserves.
i'm a watcher of Current, i'm all for leftist slants, unchecked sarcasam and big boobs, and cheekeyness. just know - way before these slicksters gave you "real, viewer content" Citizens Television was training "viewers" and maintaining the locals' rights to full media access. you want a chance for your videos to air, call CTV.
in the coming years comcast and their ilk will be looking for ways to legislate public access through the slaughterhouse. get involved locally before you no longer have the chance.

Posted by: lance | November 2, 2009 10:01 AM

It's a good thing they had a fellow leftist in the white house, because by right these guys should have had to reimburse the U.S. taxpayers for cash spent dealing with the Laura Ling/Euna Lee thing.

Special Sections

Legal Notices

Some Favorite Sites

Government/ Community Links


Flyerboard

Sponsors

N.H.I. Site Design & Development

NHI Store

Buy New Haven Independent Stuff

News Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35