His Tea Didn’t Get Cold

Paul Bass PhotoDetective Bertram Ettienne had just finished polishing off a plate of bacalao with yuca at Collado Restaurant in the Hill when a murder suspect happened to walk in. Ettienne saw no reason to jump up.

It was around noon on Monday. Ettienne (pictured at the restaurant) was sitting with his back to the wall at his usual table at the rear of Collado. Ettienne eats at the Dominican restaurant across Washington Avenue from Truman School between two and four days a week. The sofrito and sasson spices, the yellow rice and beans and chicken, the bacalao (catfish codfish) all remind him of the flavors of his parents’ native Trinidad.

Ettienne sipped a cup of Lipton tea (black, no sugar) when he saw the suspect walk in along with two friends. Ettienne had been looking for the man. Since last October he had suspected that the man had shot 26-year-old Christian “Royal” Garcia to death. Garcia and his killer apparently struggled during an attempted robbery in a basement stairwell of the Brendan Towers apartment complex (pictured) off Whalley Avenue near the Boulevard. Ettienne, the lead detective on the murder investigation, had interviewed the suspect twice; both times the suspect denied it, but offered an alibi that increasingly developed holes. By last week a judge signed off on a warrant for the suspect’s arrest.

In fact, just before leaving the police station for lunch at Collado, Ettienne had met with a colleague, Officer Dave Acosta, who works with the marshal’s service to hunt down wanted people. Ettienne gave Acosta a photo of the suspect and information about the suspect’s known addresses and associates.

Ettienne didn’t expect the suspect to walk in on his lunch.

The man had a baseball cap pulled down. Ettienne couldn’t get a full look at his face. But he was pretty sure that was the guy.

Ettienne didn’t want to jump to conclusions, though. He saw no reason to rush.

He rarely sees a reason to rush. His mom (now a retired nurse’s aide) always told him: “Think before you do things.” He tends to “take my time.”

The murder suspect accompanied his friends to the Collado counter. He kept eying Ettiene. Ettienne got up. He walked over to the suspect. He shook his hand.

“You could have said hi,” he told him.

“I said, ‘What’s up’ to you!” the suspect responded.

No reason to press the point. Ettienne had gotten the close-up look he needed. Now he had no doubt. That was the guy.

So Ettienne returned to his table and his tea.

Just The Beginning

The scene was classic Ettienne, according to his boss, Sgt. Tony Reyes, head of the detective bureau’s homicide squad.

“He’s probably one of the most methodical detectives I’ve ever met,” Reyes said. “He’s extremely thorough, extremely intelligent. He wants to get it right.”

That trait is crucial in a homicide investigation, Reyes observed. The public often wonders why it takes months or even years to solve a murder—especially in a case like this, when the police zeroed in on a prime suspect the first day. “Sometimes piecing together evidence once you’ve developed a suspect,” Reyes said, “is more difficult than developing the suspect.”

You have to develop a case that’ll stick.

That was Ettienne’s task as soon as he was named the lead detective following the discovery of Garcia’s body in the Brendan Towers stairwell shortly before 8 p.m. on Sunday Oct. 21. Garcia had been shot in the chest. He was pronounced dead at the scene.

Ettienne went to the scene, gathered information from other cops already there. He picked up names of people the murder victim may have been with. He picked up word that more than just the shooter may have been involved in the incident.

Meanwhile, 10 minutes after the shooting, a man had checked into St. Raphael’s with a bullet wound to his leg. Officers went to speak with him. He claimed an unknown person had shot him on the street by Whalley and Boulevard. Police had received no report of a shooting at that address. They found no physical evidence of gunshots at that location.

After collecting information at Brendan Towers, Ettienne and fellow detectives met with Garcia’s father and sister. They learned Garcia had moved out of his parents’ home and hadn’t shared a lot of information about his friends and whereabouts.

Ettienne returned to Brendan Towers for another evidence briefing before going home for the evening. Then began eight months of tracking down friends and associates of the victim. Tracking down addresses. Leaving cards at the door, hoping for calls back. Arranging once, twice, up to five times to meet in person for an interview. During some promising stretches, work days lasted 16 hours.

Ettienne also re-interviewed the suspect, the man who had checked himself into St. Ray’s with the bullet wound.

“At this point in time, even though I had my investigative beliefs, he was still a victim [too, of a gunshot wound]. I treated him as a victim. It was my job to do that. I always keep my options open.”

The man continued to insist he had nothing to do with Garcia’s shooting. He said he never hung around with Garcia.

Over time, witnesses and associates told a different story to Ettienne. One said the suspect had been in Garcia’s apartment the day of the shooting. Another reported someone who “looked like” the suspect at the time of the murder.

A case was gradually coming together.

Ettienne developed relationships with the suspect’s family, too, and kept tabs on him the best he could. He met with dozens of people who knew either the suspect or the Garcia, to get a picture of the fatal shooting itself (apparently a struggle in which multiple shots were fired), of Garcia (“the guy who hung out at Whalley and Boulevard and was cool with everybody”), of potential suspects.

“It’s a lot of hunting,” Ettienne said. “Locating new addresses, people calling you back if you leave the card, just getting people to talk to you. Sometimes it may take two to three weeks before you speak with someone. You might have five conversations about having a meeting. It’s not a walk in the park. Just because you have a suspect doesn’t mean you get an arrest warrant.”

Meanwhile, Ettienne kept track of the evidence. A gun was never found. He obtained a warrant to review phone records; it turned out the suspect had called Garcia shortly before Garcia’s death.

Then results finally came back from the state crime lab from tests on the clothing the suspect had worn when he entered the hospital that night. The police had obtained them as part of an investigation into the shooting of the man’s leg. The results showed gunpowder on the man’s sweats and sneakers. The results pointed to an up-close shooting. The suspect had claimed to police that someone had fired on him from a distance, too far away for him to identify the shooter.

By late last week the warrant was signed. All that remained was finding the suspect. Or, as it turned out, the suspect finding Ettienne at Collado Restaurant.

“A 45 Suspect For A Signal 7”

Before the suspect walked in, another detective, Betsy Segui, had come into Collado for lunch. She ordered chicken with peppers and sat down at Ettienne’s table.

After confirming the suspect’s identity up close, Ettienne returned to the table. He got on the police radio. He didn’t whisper, but nor did he speak too loudly. He didn’t want the suspect to hear him and then run out the door.

Fortunately, the suspect had relaxed; he was no longer eying Ettienne.

“I’m at the restaurant at Washington and Morris,” Ettienne reported to the dispatcher. “With a 45 suspect for a signal 7.” (That’s cop code for a suspect who has an arrest warrant for murder.) He requested that patrol officers be sent to the restaurant.

Just then the suspect and his friends walked back to the rear exit on their way out. Ettienne stood up again and intercepted the suspect.

“I’ve got to talk to you,” he said.

“For what?” the suspect responded.

Ettienne grabbed his arm. “You’ve got a warrant.”

He sat him down and handcuffed him. Methodically. No rush. No fuss.

The police booked the suspect, who’s 20, for murder. The suspect denied again in a conversation with detectives that he had committed the murder, Ettienne said.

Tuesday afternoon the police invited the victim’s family to headquarters for a press conference announcing the arrest. Ettienne got to feel the pride that comes, after months of painstaking labor, with telling a family a relative’s killer has been caught.

His work isn’t over. The case remains open, the arrest warrant sealed. Until a trial date, Ettienne has more evidence to gather, more leads to follow.


Read other installments in the Independent’s “Cop of the Week” series:

Shafiq Abdussabur
Craig Alston & Billy White Jr.
James Baker
Lloyd Barrett
Manmeet Bhagtana (Colon)
Paul Bicki
Paul Bicki (2)
Sheree Biros
Scott Branfuhr
Dennis Burgh
Anthony Campbell
Rob Clark & Joe Roberts
Sydney Collier
Carlos Conceicao
Carlos Conceicao (2)
Carlos Conceicao and Josh Kyle
David Coppola
Roy Davis
Joe Dease
Milton DeJesus
Brian Donnelly
Anthony Duff
Robert DuPont
Jeremie Elliott and Scott Shumway
Jose Escobar Sr.
Bertram Ettienne
Martin Feliciano & Lou DeCrescenzo
Paul Finch
Jeffrey Fletcher
Renee Forte
Marco Francia
William Gargone
William Gargone & Mike Torre
Derek Gartner
Derek Gartner & Ryan Macuirzynski
Jon Haddad & Daniela Rodriguez
Dan Hartnett
Ray Hassett
Robert Hayden
Robin Higgins
Ronnell Higgins
William Hurley & Eddie Morrone
Racheal Inconiglios
Juan Ingles
Paul Kenney
Hilda Kilpatrick
Herb Johnson
John Kaczor & Alex Morgillo
Jillian Knox
Peter Krause
Peter Krause (2)
Amanda Leyda
Rob Levy
Anthony Maio
Dana Martin
Steve McMorris
Juan Monzon
Chris Perrone
Ron Perry
Joe Pettola
Diego Quintero and Elvin Rivera
Stephanie Redding
Tony Reyes
David Rivera
Luis & David Rivera
Luis Rivera (2)
Salvador Rodriguez
Salvador Rodriguez (2)
Brett Runlett
David Runlett
Allen Smith
Marcus Tavares
Martin Tchakirides
David Totino
Stephan Torquati
Gene Trotman Jr.
Kelly Turner
Lars Vallin (& Xander)
John Velleca
Manuella Vensel
Holly Wasilewski
Holly Wasilewski (2)
Alan Wenk
Stephanija VanWilgen
Matt Williams
Michael Wuchek
Michael Wuchek (2)
David Zannelli
David Zaweski

Tags: , ,

Post a Comment

Commenting has closed for this entry


posted by: Morris Cove New on May 7, 2013  3:44pm

Great job !!! need more like him.

posted by: mm on May 7, 2013  6:29pm

Great work by the detective, but not great fact checking by the Independent.

The fish: bacalao is NOT catfish, it is dried salt cod. Bagre is catfish

[Ed: Thanks for the corrections!]

posted by: cp06 on May 7, 2013  11:03pm

@mm ....
and “sasson” is actually sazon.

In any case, great job, Det. Ettienne!

posted by: Curious on May 8, 2013  10:26am

I love this kind of article, bravo to Etienne, and NHI for bringing this to us.

posted by: JustAnotherTaxPayer on May 8, 2013  11:14am

A+, two things, when one looks at the number of people involved in this series of events, the amount of time, all coming to a focus at this time, in this place, I know Etienne realizes even though he played a big part, the safe arrest, without TV drama, going down so calmly, with so many people around, not knowing if the suspect was armed, or his friends, a greater power orchestrates many of these moments not only for police, but for everyone. God Blesses you sometimes, and when it goes the other way, no matter how painful, no matter how senseless, we all have to find some inner peace. No matter if it feels good, or if it gives you heartache, that sometimes haunts you at times when you cannot control.

The second thing is I would not want to walk into a poker game and see Etienne on the other side of the table.

Good Luck, Good Health, Peace, and Love.