“Brown-Eyed Girl” Learns The Beat

DSCN5698.JPGcopoftheweek_logo.jpgThe sun was setting the other night as “Messy” rode by Congress Market on his bike. Officer Manmeet Bhagtana yelled hello.

Messy, who’s 17 and in trouble with the law a lot, can’t say Bhagtana’s name.

Messy does know her. He waved hello, then turned the corner.

Most people Bhagtana (pictured) runs into on the beat in the Hill neighborhood either don’t know or can’t remember her name.

The kids on the street call her “Brown-Eyed Girl. Or they call her and her partner, Officer Mary Helland, “the two girl cops.” As in: “There go the two girl cops.”

Bhagtana doesn’t mind. As long as they respect her—and talk with her. Whether or not (or especially if) they’re in trouble. In turn, she makes sure to learn their names, their nicknames, where they hang out, even how they walk.

“As long as they recognize we’re here, that’s all that matters,” Bhagtana said.

She has been learning about that, about how to become a trusted and respected neighborhood presence, on the 7 p.m. to 3 a.m. shift in the Hill North district. That’s prime time for shootings and domestic disturbances.

Bhagtana, a 23-year-old Mumbai native who moved with her family to Queens when she was 10, worked her way through University of New Haven in order to study criminal justice. (She watched a lot of Law and Order growing up.) She graduated from the police academy last December.

Since the spring she has been assigned to the Hill, learning the ropes of community policing under the general tutelage of district manager Lt. Holly Wasilewski.

“Seeing [a woman] in a position like that, it challenges me,” Bhagtana said. “It motivates me to be in a position like hers one day.”

Bhagtana is learning those community policing lessons more immediately while walking the beat with partner Helland, a five-year veteran of the force. They’re the New Haven force’s only two-female patrol team. “We’re like sisters,” they said.

One of the first lessons came this May, during one of Bhagtana’s first rounds with Helland. The lesson involved Messy.

“Pray For Me”

DSCN5714.JPGAll that Bhagtana knew at first was that a teenaged boy had been shot on Howard Avenue. She and Helland (at right in photo) went to Yale-New Haven to see him.

Bhagtana watched as Messy, in obvious pain, greeted Helland.

“Come here Helland,” Messy said.

“Can you pray for me, Helland?” he said. “It hurts so bad. I just want you to know.”

Someone had shot Messy in the shoulder. Although he’d turn out fine, at the moment the pain was excruciating.

It turned out that Helland knew Messy so well because she’d been arresting him since he was 14.

“This kid just got shot, and he saying that to her. I’m watching him. He actually held her hand,” Bhagtana recalled in a conversation this week near the substation at Congress and Hallock.

That was no isolated encounter, Bhagtana learned. Helland seemed to know everyone. People seemed to trust her, even if she’d arrested them.

Officer Helland (at right in photo) said she “never thought I’d have a relationship with these kids” when she was first assigned to a walking beat on Stevens Street five years ago. Helland is 31. A third-generation Fair Havener (her grandfather attended Strong School), she originally thought she’d become a nurse. She became a cop instead.

You get to know people better based on how you approach them, Helland said. “It doesn’t have to be yelling and pulling out your nightstick.”

She discovered that many kids want adults, including cops, to pay attention to them, even if that attention involves confronting them for doing wrong.

She got to know the kids partly by taking them out of town. For four summers she along with other officers brought dozens of “at risk” Hill teens to Camp Rell for a week of camping out, mile runs, sit ups, competitions, leading up to an awards ceremony with the National Guard. (The program was canceled this year due to the state budget crunch.)

Bhagtana watched another one of Helland’s relationships help defuse a family dispute one night earlier this month. A woman called them to Hallock Street to report her 16 year-old daughter missing. She and the daughter had been arguing. The girl was pregnant. Mom wanted her to have an abortion. The girl didn’t want to.

Helland knows the girl’s father, BJ. He lives across town in Newhallville.

The people in that household, including BJ, get in trouble with the law. Bhagtana and Helland drove there. Bhagtana didn’t know if BJ and his household would cooperate, let alone open the door.

The cops were welcomed inside. The daughter was there.

“I saw how [Helland] was relating to them,” Bhagtana recalled. “They could have refused entry to the house.”

Inside, Helland discussed the situation with the family. The girl said she couldn’t productively speak one-on-one with her mother. Helland suggested that the two set up a meeting with a neutral third party. She referred them to a school-based counselor.

“I tell them, ‘Today’s today,’” Helland said of her approach to people like BJ or Messy when she arrests them. “‘Tomorrow’s another day, a clean slate.’”

Car Radar

Bhagtana also noticed how Helland gets to know not just the people, but the cars they drive—down to the license plates. When a plate number came over the radio, Helland sometimes recognize whose car it belongs to, and where to find it.

On the overnight shift, productive cases can begin with keeping tabs on cars. One night in June Helland and Bhagtana noticed the driver of a Honda with tinted windows cutting off another driver at Kossuth and Congress. The officers tried to stop the Honda. The driver refused to stop. A chase ensued.

Bhagtana was behind the wheel. She’d never chased a driver before.

“It was nerve-wracking,” she recalled. She was thinking, “Oh gosh, I hope I don’t crash!”

Fortunately, the driver was fleeing, but not speeding. The driver braked a lot, then starting back up.

Finally the Honda stopped at the intersection of Frank and Lines.

“We thought they were going to bail out of the car and start running different ways,” Bhagtana recalled. She and Helland hurried to the Honda. They pulled three men out; the men didn’t resist. Then Helland checked the car—and found a .32 caliber Beretta.

It turned out the gun had been used in five shootings in the Hill. And it turned out the gun wasn’t registered to any of the men in the car. It was registered to a Waterbury police sergeant. After a subsequent investigation police arrested the man for alleged illegal transfers of guns and stockpiling weapons and explosives in his Westville home. (The sergeant has pleaded not guilty to the charges.)

Continuing Ed

DSCN5724.JPGAlthough out of the academy for almost a year, Bhagtana is still in some respects in school as she picks up tips from her more experienced colleagues.

“She wants to learn. She’ll ask you a lot of questions,” Lt. Wasilewski said. “It’s refreshing. She really wants to work out here and do her job.”

Hill South cops organize community events like cook-outs and, at summer’s end, a giveaway of backpacks filled with school supplies. Wasilewski doesn’t have to encourage Bhagtana to take part on her after-work hours. Instead, she recently had to tell Bhagtana it was OK to miss one event. “I told her, ‘There’ll be other events.’” A Halloween party’s coming up.

Helland said Bhagtana picks up on lessons quick. One recent day a man walking down Congress Avenue spotted “the two girl cops.” He slipped his hood over his head so they couldn’t see his face.

“That’s Digler,” Baghtana told Helland. “I can tell by the way he walks.”

The man was wanted for violating probation. They proceeded to place him into custody.

Read other installments in the Independent’s “Cop of the Week” series:

Shafiq Abdussabur
Scott Branfuhr
Dennis Burgh
Sydney Collier
David Coppola
Joe Dease
Brian Donnelly
Anthony Duff
Bertram Etienne
Paul Finch
Jeffrey Fletcher
Renee Forte
William Gargone & Mike Torre
Jon Haddad & Daniela Rodriguez
Dan Hartnett
Ray Hassett
Robin Higgins
Ronnell Higgins
Racheal Inconiglios
Hilda Kilpatrick
Anthony Maio
Steve McMorris
Stephanie Redding
Tony Reyes
Luis & David Rivera
Salvador Rodriguez
Brett Runlett
David Runlett
Marcus Tavares
Martin Tchakirides
Stephan Torquati
Kelly Turner
John Velleca
Alan Wenk
Michael Wuchek
David Zannelli
David Zaweski

(To suggest an officer to be featured, contact us here.)

Post a Comment

Commenting has closed for this entry


posted by: New_Haven_Resident on October 23, 2009  1:43pm

For four summers she along with other officers brought dozens of “at risk” Hill teens to Camp Rell for a week of camping out, mile runs, sit ups, competitions, leading up to an awards ceremony with the National Guard. (The program was canceled this year due to the state budget crunch.)

Is sad that the city or state canceled this program, that will help our youth. Where are they getting the money from, to put nice pretty flowers around the Yale area and downtown area. Also the lights on the christmas tree that we just got yesterday.  These kids are our future we are talking about. Then they wonder why there are so many kids getting hurt or shot.

posted by: Whoa on October 23, 2009  2:14pm

Whoa, where do they find these cops?  She is beautiful!  I wouldn’t mind being arrested by her…

posted by: kamb on October 23, 2009  11:32pm

Great article. Keep up the good work.

And to NEW HAVEN RESIDENT, save your nonsense for another thread. The kids don’t get to go to Camp Rell, beuause we’re all feeling the pain of the ressesion, and some things have to get cut. Now these kids are going to go out and ‘get shot’ you say?! Stop. There’s other things they can do while our tax dollars get reallocated.

posted by: Doug on October 23, 2009  11:49pm

Best of luck & be safe officer!

posted by: leslie on October 24, 2009  3:08pm

you say it well new_haven_resident. how dare we celebrate holidays when whats necessary is forgotten. this camp was important for building relationships.  luckily the hill has officer bhagtana.  beautiful picture paul.  but i would have edited that second part of “whoa’s” comment.  cmon whoa, its time we moved past your offensive objectification of women.

posted by: streever on October 24, 2009  8:27pm

Officer Bhagtana,  thank you! An excellent example of community policing: I’m proud to hear about your work & see you on here. This is an excellent cop of the week piece.

Thanks NHI, and NHPD.

posted by: streever on October 24, 2009  10:01pm

Leslie: I was as OK with that comment as I was with the dozen or so comments about Lt Velleca & the male officer the week after. I don’t think it’s particularly harmful, although I do find the comments silly. The even-nature of it makes me feel like it might be OK.

[Editor’s note: Thanks Streever & Leslie, for raising this debate. I did struggle with whether to run that comment and wasn’t sure whether to post it. We did choose not to run several comment submitted for both stories that were more graphic and objectifying…]

posted by: nfjanette on October 26, 2009  1:26pm

Judging by her proven professional competence, officer Bhagtana would seem to be perfectly capable of deciding how she wishes to appear in public and how to deal with the reaction of people.  If dealing with comments on the web about her appearance are the toughest challenge rather than a car chase or fighting with a suspect, I expect she would call it a good day indeed.  Of course, I would not put it past some people to bicycle on the sidewalk or down the street against traffic or to jaywalk within her sight in hopes of a stern reprimand.

posted by: topnotch on October 26, 2009  3:43pm

Wow.Talk about the American dream. This woman immigrated to the United states, had a dream, and achieved it. What an asset to New Haven. Excellent story. BTW where they heck does New Haven find such gorgeous cops?