On Thursday, Nov. 19, the Southern Connecticut State University (SCSU) Psychology Department and its Journal of Student Psychological Research held a Forum on Early Literacy Experiences, the Brain, and Child Development. Held at the Adanti Student Center at SCSU with support also from the Literacy Coalition of Greater New Haven, the event featured a panel of the following speakers:
*Perri Klass, M.D., national medical director of Reach Out and Read; columnist, New York Times
*Myra Jones-Taylor, Ph.D., commissioner of early childhood, State of Connecticut (1)
*Julia Irwin, Ph.D., associate professor of psychology, SCSU; senior scientist, Haskins Laboratories
*Laura Raynolds, Ph.D., associate professor of special education and reading, SCSU; research affiliate, Haskins Laboratories (moderator).
Cheryl Durwin, Ph.D., professor of psychology at SCSU and a Literacy Coalition board member, was the event’s primary organizer. Christine Garber, Connecticut director of Reach Out and Read, was also instrumental. The audience included numerous early childhood teachers as well as various other educators, researchers, nonprofit staffers, and volunteers – not to mention parents.
After welcoming remarks from Cheryl Durwin, moderator Laura Raynolds introduced the panel, beginning with Perri Klass.
“Your Baby Will Love Books Because Your Baby Loves You”
Perri Klass is a pediatrician, a professor of journalism, an author of books, a columnist for the New York Times, and a longtime leader of Reach Out and Read, through which pediatricians and other medical providers around the country discuss reading with parents of young children and distribute books. Her presentation was on how “Books Build Better Brains.” Highlighting aspects of “early brain and child development” (or EBCD – “the most important thing in the world”), she emphasized that it “happens in large part through interactions and relationships,” which she underscored as “hugely important.” By reading to young children, parents or educators are teaching “responsiveness” and cultivating “routines, structures” that will help children “feel safe.” According to Dr. Klass, “Your baby will love books because your baby loves you.” She acknowledged that cognitive and social/emotional development occur “over time,” through many experiences, but we should recognize key “windows” for learning.
Such learning is both positive and protective. There is a “proliferation” of “connections, of synapses” before “selective pruning” advances, for example to focus on the most useful sounds in a given language. Therefore the number of words as well as “the quality, the nature of the language” matter. In addition to citing the 1995 Hart/Risley study of the substantial “word gap” evident by age 3, correlated with a family’s socioeconomic status (SES), Dr. Klass mentioned a 2013 Stanford study by Anne Fernald et al. that found a 6-month disparity in children’s “processing speed” by age 24 months – that is, the average “higher SES” child of 18 months could process language at the speed of the average “lower SES child” of 24 months. (2) So, Dr. Klass said, “lack of stimulation” can be a problem that affects a child’s trajectory early on. Further, since “adverse events and toxic stress” (see a study of Adverse Childhood Experiences, or ACE) can have harmful effects, children need the “buffer” from stress that security provides. She said, “That’s why it matters so much” that we start early, reading to and with young children: prompts and response, “face time and lap time,” story structure and sequence, voice and visuals and print are mutually reinforcing.
As her August New York Times article described, a recent functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study revealed the activation of key regions of the brain when kids were exposed to picture books with appropriate text. As “we were designed to talk” rather than to read, the aural and the visual are closely linked in facilitating gradual understanding of print. Since its founding more than two decades ago, Reach Out and Read has deployed medical providers to build upon such understandings to help families read to their babies. The program has doctors and nurses offer guidance about “developmentally and culturally appropriate” ways to read to children, beginning at age six months, or earlier. Nationally Reach Out and Read touches some 4.6 million children annually through more than 20,000 medical providers. In Connecticut, tens of thousands of kids are served each year. The program includes volunteer readers, encouraging evaluation results, and Web resources in Spanish as well as English (and books in additional languages).
“Positive Early Experiences to Promote Language and Literacy”
Julia Irwin has written a recent book (with coauthor Dina Moore) on Preparing Children for Reading Success and is a board member of Read to Grow. Professor Irwin’s remarks, on “Positive Early Experiences to Promote Language and Literacy,” began with her citing a 1999 NAEYC report on early reading as “one of the best predictors” for a variety of positive developmental outcomes, academic and otherwise. Because “learning to read is critical,” she asserted, “we can’t leave it up to chance” – and “it begins with oral language.” Hearing language through song, speech, and play, and increasing vocabulary – “the launchpad” – are essential. She proposed a “big five” list of ingredients to help young readers and young people develop:
*Book-handling skills and concepts about print (differentiating among symbols);
*Phonological awareness, of the different sounds associated with spoken words (she cited Dr. Seuss, specifically Hop on Pop, as a rhyming example);
*Vocabulary development, including from hearing, engaging, and acting out verbs;
*Social-emotional factors (e.g., modeling patience, fostering attention, learning “to interact reciprocally” and “take turns” and “identify emotions”).
Myra Jones-Taylor is Connecticut’s first commissioner of the Office of Early Childhood (OEC), established in 2013. A cultural anthropologist, she is also – like the other speakers – a mother. She began her presentation on “Early Literacy and Early Childhood Education” by recounting an incident from the night before, when her own 10- and 12-year-old children recalled having learned the word “doldrums” years before from a book by children’s author Bill Peet. Inspired by the memory, her children “curled up” with their mom to re-read the story years after encountering it. The anecdote vividly demonstrated the complementary benefits of reading together, of books in the home, and of their social-emotional as well as cognitive value.
Start Early; Build Attachment; “Literacy-Rich Environments”
Commissioner Jones-Taylor discussed the agency’s work (with particular attention to the “building blocks of early literacy.” Acknowledging the two prior presenters, she focused on six points:
*Early childhood starts at birth, with 85% of a child’s brain architecture present by age 3 (when pre-K begins), and the most “critical period for language acquisition” before age 7, with Patricia Kuhl’s TED talk recommended;
*“Building attachment” (not to be confused, the commissioner said, with “attachment parenting”) – underscoring how young children “with secure attachments” can develop strong “relationships” and “maintain emotional balance,” and citing sources including Jack Shonkoff at Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child. (3)
*Literacy-rich environments and how whenever she visits early childhood education (ECE) centers, the number of books, their quality/appropriateness, and their physical accessibility on the shelf are “the first thing” she looks for – as she keeps in mind that middle-income neighborhoods have some 13 books per child, versus 1 book for every 300 children in low-income neighborhoods (according to a 2006 Handbook of Early Literacy Research), with correlations to average reading proficiency and ultimately graduation rates. (4)
*The ECE workforce, because even though “literacy starts at home” (and parents of varying literacy levels can support kids’ language development), teachers of young children are highly influential and, she said, are too often “at risk for functional illiteracy” themselves, with one study suggesting as many as one million ECE teachers nationally are in that category. Declaring respectfully that “we need to do better,” she noted requirements for July 2017 and July 2020 that will gradually demand that half and then all of the “lead teachers” in Connecticut’s state-funded early care and education programs hold at least a bachelor’s degree.
*Early learning and development standards (ELDS);
*Technology and early literacy – the virtues and tradeoffs of technology: “How much is too much?” and “How can families use technology to support literacy?”
Moderator Laura Raynolds summarized the three presenters’ concerns and insights. As an educator of teachers, she sees how expectations for what children are to learn in kindergarten have “risen,” with the result that “pre-K is a lot like kindergarten used to be.” Concerned about “equity” and the early appearance of achievement gaps, she observed: “As a society, we really have to think about putting more investment” into high-quality early learning.
She then invited questions, which began with an inquiry about ways that early childhood educators (ECE) can complement and supplement the reading and talking that families do at home. Other questions explored technology – for instance, how effectively students may learn from “sitting in front of monitors” with limited human engagement – and whether too much didactic instruction at too young an age might turn off kids if “the balance of the whole child gets lost.”
Panelists responded by elaborating on their earlier themes. As all of the speakers had recognized the integrated dimension of social, emotional, and cognitive learning, Perri Klass emphasized how meeting people “where they are” and connecting with them (whether parents or children) as early as possible is advisable in medicine and education alike. Her experience with Reach Out and Read, and Julia Irwin’s with Read to Grow, emerged as examples.
Technology’s Tradeoffs, Unknowns
Regarding technology, the latter observed that learning requires many more repetitions “if it doesn’t come from a person” but instead from a screen. Myra Jones-Taylor (whose presentation had already flagged this issue’s complexity) mentioned a book – Tap, Click, Read – while Laura Raynolds spoke of Maryanne Wolf’s book on “The Story and Science of the Reading Brain,” and reading via print versus screens. (5) Another resource is Common Sense Media, while new technology is being used to assess and, it’s hoped, to propel Providence families’ use of oral language in their homes through the “Providence Talks” initiative. (6)
1) The November 19 event was Myra Jones-Taylor’s second appearance in the Literacy Forum series. Previously, she participated in a 2013 program, “It’s about WORDS,” with Sandra Malmquist and Cyd Oppenheimer.
2) Stanford Professor Anne Fernald concluded, “It’s clear that SES is not destiny…. The good news is that regardless of economic circumstances, parents who use more and richer language with their infants can help their child to learn more quickly.”
An author of a larger, 2015 study of data on children at ages 2 and 5—Paul Morgan of Penn State—told Education Week, “Something that is malleable and can be affected by practitioners or by parents, is children’s vocabulary size. And it really does seem to matter in terms of preparing the children both academically and behaviorally for kindergarten.”
An organization working—including via Twitter—to #CloseTheWordGap is Too Small to Fail.
3) Besides the Center at Harvard and SCSU itself, the Yale Child Study Center is an additional university resource.
4) Websites including this government site attribute this comparison of neighborhoods to Susan B. Neuman and David K. Dickinson, ed. Handbook of Early Literacy Research, Volume 2. New York, NY: 2006, p. 31.)
5) In a 2014 Washington Post article, Maryanne Wolf was quoted: “We can’t turn back…. We should be simultaneously reading to children from books, giving them print, helping them learn this slower mode, and at the same time steadily increasing their immersion into the technological, digital age. It’s both. We have to ask the question: What do we want to preserve?” More on Maryanne Wolf’s work can be found in the New Yorker and on WBUR.
6) Natasha Singer’s November 2015 New York Times article on “The Digital Disparities Facing Lower-Income Teenagers” cited a Common Sense Media report by Vicky Rideout. The Times article quoted Ellen Wartella of Northwestern University: “When there are disparities, even if it’s a question of how smart your phone is, teens and tweens may not have access to what they need — not just for school, but for other parts of their lives as well…. They aren’t able to participate in the way that more wealthy teens and tweens are able to.” Yet, according to the Times, “teenagers in lower-income households typically spent about eight hours on daily screen media use compared with less than six hours for those from higher-income families, the report said.” The Times continued, “Dr. Wartella said the reported differences in media use among the various teenage and tween subgroups raised new questions for researchers. ‘What specific content are these user groups exposed to?... What impact does it have on their social relationships, their attitudes and their knowledge?... We don’t know enough about that.’”
The Literacy Coalition of Greater New Haven – sponsor of the Literacy Forum series – is a nonprofit, all-volunteer organization with a mission to promote, support, and advance literacy for people of all ages. Visit LiteracyEveryday to share or obtain information on free events, resources, and ways to get involved in pursuit of a region of readers.
There is a need for additional volunteer tutors and mentors at such organizations as the Boys and Girls Club, Jewish Coalition for Literacy, Junta for Progressive Action, Literacy Volunteers of Greater New Haven, New Haven Public School Foundation, and New Haven Reads.
Neighbors are invited to visit the Literacy Resource Center on Winchester Avenue, in space at 4 Science Park donated by Science Park Development Corporation. The Literacy Resource Center, or LRC, represents a partnership among Concepts for Adaptive Learning, the Coalition, New Haven Reads, Literacy Volunteers, and the Economic Development Corporation. Upstairs in the same building at 4 Science Park are the offices, classrooms, and art gallery of the Connecticut Center for Arts and Technology (ConnCAT).
You can help by:
• Reading in the home, promoted by libraries such as the New Haven Public Library—and involving grandparents as well as parents, and free books from sources including Read to Grow and New Haven Reads;
• Encouraging friends, family, and others to seek literacy assistance whenever useful;
• Volunteering as a tutor or mentor;
• Bolstering literacy in other ways, such as through donations of money—whether directly, via the Community Foundation or the United Way—or of books and by advocating and voting.
For more information: firstname.lastname@example.org
Articles on the Coalition and its events: