“Let Us Live Our Dreams”

The bad guy in all this was Obama who gave people false hope with an action he knew to be unconstitutional. Now Congress has to act. Let's hope they do the right thing. Sometimes you need to put pressure on people to do what they should have done to begin with.

How come these same Black leaders in these pictures are a afraid to speak about reparation for black people.In fact were was Knee Grow Leaders when Haitian Immigrants was being sent back.

Black, Undocumented And Fighting To Survive
Hidden in plain sight, Black immigrants are erased and deported without anyone checking twice.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/undocumented-black_us_593178eae4b075bff0f2b281

The bad guy in all of this is Trump, who has built his Nazi and Klan base on demonizing people so much greater than him. Get it right, you sympathizer.

"The arousing of prejudice, pity, anger, and similar emotions has nothing to do with the essential facts, but is merely a personal appeal to the man who is judging the case. Consequently if the rules for trials which are now laid down some states-especially in well-governed states-were applied everywhere, such people would have nothing to say. All men, no doubt, think that the laws should prescribe such rules, but some, as in the court of Areopagus, give practical effect to their thoughts and forbid talk about non-essentials. This is sound law and custom. It is not right to pervert the judge by moving him to anger or envy or pity-one might as well warp a carpenter's rule before using it. Again, a litigant has clearly nothing to do but to show that the alleged fact is so or is not so, that it has or has not happened. As to whether a thing is important or unimportant, just or unjust, the judge must surely refuse to take his instructions from the litigants: he must decide for himself all such points as the law-giver has not already defined for him."

--Aristotle

My understanding is that constitutionally and legally Mr. Trump acted correctly as regards to DACA., whereas Mr. Obama did not. This is the responsibility of Congress to fix this problem. While it seems improbable, based on their inability to work together to pass any law, only Congress has the true legislative power to make this right. Though a POTUS may be frustrated with Congress's lack of productivity, he/she may not make the kind of executive action that Mr. Obama made several years ago – and one that had so widespread an impact affecting so many (800,000) people. This is not the legal, constitutional purpose of what an executive action is supposed to be – no matter how sympathetic you may be towards the "Dreamers". The immigration laws in America are a mess and will no doubt get even messier. However, IMHO, the only way to pull ourselves out of this mess is to start by enforcing laws already on the books or by changing these laws through the constitutional process. By ignoring or subverting the law because we are sympathetic or empathetic to a cause is a slippery slope to an even more dysfunctional country that is one small step closer to some kind of anarchy. The law regarding the "Dreamers" should be changed, but only Congress can do it.

Fact Error Notes:

Once again Noteworthy attacks good and hardworking people who are major contributors to the US. Meanwhile he defends alleged pedophiles and argues that people who commit sexual assault against 14 year olds shouldn't be held accountable. This is the opposition to DACA.

BevHills:

Glad you can copy and paste. It's no more accurate than the last time. Perhaps in the future, you can be relevant too.

Just for the record - not attacking "hard working" people. I'm attacking the specious argument that POTUS should continue what the U.S. Supreme Court deemed unconstitutional - and give the do nothing Congress, with its posing and preening Congressmen and woman a pass. It is their responsibility, has always been their responsibility to address the Dreamer issue - and the mess that has become immigration in this country. If these slobs would work longer than 3 days a week - stop taking month long vacations - they could actually get something done.

Since 1986 citizens have told Washington to tighten the borders as well as immigration reform. We have heard the phrase "COMPREHENSIVE immigration legislation" at nauseam for over 20 years. The term has become congresses go to phrase for avoiding making a hard choice. So yesterday President Trump told the Congress that time's up, you have six months, to do your job or else. Congress in its all to common pathetic response cries that the president is not leading them but scolding them. For the past 8 years Congress forgot they are an equal branch of government. If they dont want the responsibility then why not just install a monarchy.

Noteworthy can you point to the Supreme Court ruling on the constitutionality of DACA?

Why do you keep going on about the rule of law while advocating for a legal environment that allows for sexual assault on 14 year olds?

Educate yourself.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/06/22/us/who-is-affected-by-supreme-court-decision-on-immigration.html?_r=0

Since you clearly don't have much faith in due process or having judicial findings of guilt before judging one guilty - I won't waste my time on the rest of your comment.

Did you read the article? "The status of young people who had qualified for the initial DACA program, which was created in 2012, were not at issue in the Supreme Court case."

So you judge a program unconstitutional due to a split Supreme Court decision that didn't rule on the status of people who qualified for DACA?

Seems like you have a lot more empathy for alleged pedophiles and people who sexually assualt 14 year olds than you do for hardworking people who never committed a crime in their entire lives. Sounds like classic Noteworthy notes to me.