Harp: Fight Census Question

Christopher Peak PhotoMayor Toni Harp called on people to let Washington, D.C. know that undocumented immigrants live here and should count toward our official population figures.

Harp made the call on her recent appearance on WNHH FM’s “Mayor Monday” program, a day after participating in a Council of State Governments panel on immigration.

She asked listeners to write to the U.S. Commerce Department and to members of Congress to oppose a plan by the Trump administration to reintroduce a question on the 2020 census form asking participants to check off that they are citizens. Harp, like other mayors dealing with undocumented residents, fears that the presence of the question will dissuade many immigrants from completing the census form, because they fear being deported.

That means New Haven and other Northeastern cities could lose representation in Congress, or at least lose aid tied to population, Harp noted.

The census last asked the question in 1950. (Click here for a rundown on the issue.)

“A lot of people there are concerned,” she said. “It’s something that everyone should be concerned with.”

“The real question is whether this census will make our population decrease.”

Harp said that the city suffered 20 years ago when many undocumented immigrants were left out of the census. As a result, the city’s population was undercounted.

She credited her predecessor, Mayor John DeStefano, for recognizing that problem and fixing it.

“They worked really, really hard in the next census to make people comfortable filling it out, no matter what your level of documentation. People did. And we moved from the third largest city to the second largest city [in Connecticut]. Our population increased,” Harp said.

She has signed a letter along with other mayors across the country calling on the Trump administration and Congress to elminate the check off.  The letter argues that the addition of the question “threatens the Census Bureau’s ability to conduct an inclusive enumeration that accurately reflects the diverse fabric of America.” (Read the full letter here.)

At Sunday’s panel, which took place in Rye, N.Y. at the state governments group’s annual conference, Harp shared a panel with legislators from Puerto Rico and Rhode Island along with Erika Tindill, a Connecticut family court judge who lives in New Haven. Tindall spoke of how undocumented parents in her court sometimes sign on to agreements they normally would oppose for fear of returning to court, because federal immigration agents have been showing up at local courthouses.

Harp also heard on the panel about how hundreds of Puerto Ricans displaced by Hurricane Maria were brought to the mainland by ministers — who then placed them in a sex trafficking operation. She said she spoke of New Haven’s positive experience welcoming and resettling Maria evacuees.

Mayor: Borrowing Prevented State Takeover

Also on the program, which occurred on her 71st birthday, Harp defended her administration’s decision to refinance $160 million of debt to close a budget deficit. If not for the refinancing, New Haven would have “probably” ended up “very close” to bankruptcy, triggering a state takeover of its finances, she said.

She reiterated a commitment to work with alders on a five-year plan to stabilize city finances. She predicted the plan would be ocmpleted by late December or January and serve as a guide for future budgets, with commitments to put adequate money each year into pensions and the city’s rainy day fund. She predicted that would please bond rating agencies that recently downgraded the city. So will the next police contract, she said, because it will likely see savings in health benefits, one of the rating agencies’ stated concerns.

Harp also responded “absolutely” when a caller asked if she intends to run for reelection next year.


Click on the video to watch the full episode of “Mayor Monday” on WNHH FM.

This episode of “Mayor Monday” was made possible with the support of Gateway Community College and Berchem Moses PC.

Tags: ,

Post a Comment

Commenting has closed for this entry


posted by: Ulmus Civitas on August 6, 2018  8:01pm

She’s running? Again? In the words of McEnroe, “you cannot be serious!” ...God help us. We need someone to step up to the plate, here.

posted by: Noteworthy on August 6, 2018  8:07pm

Mayor Harp has nobody to blame but herself for the city’s fiscal woes. She has now signed up taxpayers to pay twice as much in debt. It is her lavish spending, failure to mitigate overtime, curb expenses and take prudent measures during her four years in office that got us to the brink of insolvency. she is doing what she has done in her personal and political life. It has now put us all in jeopardy. I can’t wait for her to run again. Will she lie again about balanced budgets?

posted by: robn on August 7, 2018  5:18am

The recent bonding of debt was the equivalent of a gigantic payday loan, incurring $84 million dollars of extra interest payments handed down to future generations of new Haveners. Not something to be proud of. The city should be in bankruptcy because it’s got no fiscal discipline.

posted by: 1644 on August 7, 2018  6:21am

New Haven was not cut $10 million.  New Haven received $10 million less than the Governor’s initial budget proposal, a proposal which included a massive increase in aid to cities. an amount Harp and the BoA recklessly included in their budget, while simultaneously not budgeting for a $15 million Teacher’s Retirement contribution, a program also included in the Governor’s budget. Malloy’s budget represented a huge shift of cost burdens to the suburbs, something that was not going to happen in a suburban state.

What’s shocking about this interview is that Harp knew the city was headed for bankruptcy, yet not only made no budget adjustments during the fiscal year, but continued with frivolous spending like her China trip and police drivers.  Unfortunately, she faces no meaningful opposition in this one-party town, and low-information voters (like my brother, who accepts her “the state cut us” rationale, will re-elect her.

posted by: NHPLEB on August 7, 2018  6:22am

The census statement is an attempt by the mayor to deflect attention from the fiscal shambles that the city is in.  It’s what every politician does to shift people’s attention away from the serious issues at hand.  NH leaders opened the doors as a sanctuary city.  Now,  they should be ready to accept the consequences of their thoughtless decision.

AS a PS:  I will not vote for any incumbent for any office, on any level of govt.  We need new people.  A newbie couldn’t do worse than what we have now…..

posted by: robn on August 7, 2018  6:48am


Don’t drive like my brother either.

posted by: JCFremont on August 7, 2018  6:56am

So wouldn’t that give a more accurate list to document the undocumented? Or is it more advantages to use abstract numbers? Of course it is this is politics not accounting.

posted by: TheMadcap on August 7, 2018  9:12am

“So wouldn’t that give a more accurate list to document the undocumented?”

Not if the goal is to discourage them from answering to begin with

posted by: 1644 on August 7, 2018  10:07am

NHPLEB:  There seem to be a few Alders who are doing their best to be responsible.  Roth and Winter stand out,  with Festa and some others not too bad.  As far as I can tell, Roth and Winter serve solely out of civic mindedness, while most of the rest “serve” to get their piece of the pie or advance a cause like UNITE-HERE.